Our quasi-DIY wedding invitations: The breakdown
Several months ago, Casey asked for a tutorial on how our wedding invitations came to be. I finally dug out the photos of the invitations (three months after our wedding!) so here we go.
In terms of cost, I was actually surprised by how much we’d spent. I’d initially budgeted $500 for our invitations without having any idea of how much invitations cost. We tried to be cost-conscious in the process but didn’t want to spare any details.
In terms of time, these took forever. I’m not kidding anybody though - I loved putting these together and didn’t mind the time factor at all.

Postage ($119) - Each envelope cost $.81 so in theory we should have spent around $90. I’m not sure how I ended up with an extra $30 worth of stamps. I was slightly picky at the post office with which stamps we used - the classic wedding stamp just wasn’t our style.
Vintage stamps for decoration ($9) - I bought these on eBay when we first got engaged, knowing I would use them for something, and I ended up first affixing the real postage, then glue-sticking the old stamps on for decoration. I confirmed with the post office that the vintage stamps wouldn’t prevent the invites from being sent properly and everyone ended up receiving theirs just fine.
Calligraphy ($0) - The pseudo-calligraphy was free, thanks to my artistic mama and her nice handwriting. It’s not true calligraphy but it’s better than regular hand-writing and, oh, FREE.

Return address labels ($0) - Jessica designed them in PowerPoint, then I made a couple changes and printed them on my home printer on ivory cardstock which I already had. I punched out the circles using a punch I’d already purchased for other wedding projects, then Mark and I glue-sticked them onto the backs of the envelopes. I had originally wanted to order custom return address labels but time simply ran out and we had to make-do.
Notice more vintage stamps sealing the belly band?

Vintage map envelope liners ($23) - These were hand-cut from two vintage atlases that I bought on eBay. Again, I purchased them early on and didn’t know exactly how I would use them. I made a template for the envelope liner by hand and then cut them all out using good old-fashioned scissors. Some were more perfectly cut than others and some had prettier map designs (this is a particularly bad one - the good ones went to our guests!). I glue-sticked them all into the envelopes by hand.

First of all, my MS Paint skillz ROCK.
Envelopes, pocketfolds, invitations, RSVP card, directions card, details card, custom map, belly bands ($593) - These were all designed by Wenda of Tucci Paper Co. I initially wanted my step-sister to design the invitations for free but with a toddler and a newborn, she didn’t exactly have the free time to make things to my liking.
We didn’t want to spend the money, but I started trolling Etsy anyway for wedding invitations. Most designers have Etsy shops with samples of their work but will customize anything you want. I found a handful of artists I liked, made an Excel matrix to compare levels of liking, price per invite, etc, etc and decided on Wenda.
I loved her work but in the end wasn’t completely satisfied with her service. She didn’t get back to my emails in a timely manner and got the invitations to me nearly a week late after I reminded her my payment had been sitting in her account for a week. Everything ended up turning out just fine and we were pleased with both the quality and design of the invitations.
Misc supplies: glue sticks ($3), tape tabs ($2)
The total came to $750 for 110 invites or $6.81/invitation, not including, of course, my many (MANY) hours spent putting the invitations together. And here is the final invitation suite:

We received SO MANY compliments on our invitations and they truly were my labor of love. I’m glad we spent the time and money on them and if you don’t have a grand and then some to spend on a custom letterpress suite, I totally recommend going this route and I can almost guarantee they’ll be much more impressive!